…yet another rejection from The New York Times. [Updated]
It's long been a dream of mine to be published in "Modern Love."
Do you know it? It's a weekly New York Times column "about relationships, feelings, betrayals, and revelations." It's also a TV show, a podcast, and a book.
"Modern Love" stories are real, raw, honest, sometimes funny, oftentimes heartbreaking, but always, without fail, wonderfully written and edited. They're also extremely hard to get published. In fact, the odds of getting your submission selected are estimated to be between 0.5% and 1%.
And yet I keep trying—and failing.
Below is the response I received on my most recent submission.
Dear Corey,
Thank you for sending your writing to Modern Love. Although I don't find your essay right for our needs, I'm grateful to have had the opportunity to consider it. I regret that the volume of submissions we receive makes it impractical for me to offer editorial feedback.
Best wishes,
Daniel Jones, Modern Love editor
Maybe I'm aiming too high?
I've had four "Tiny Love Stories"—an offshoot of the main "Modern Love" column—published in The New York Times in the last few years, and I'm proud of them. Each one was a big deal for me. But I'm still oh-for-two on The Big One. And yes, I know "Modern Love" has incredibly long odds, but it's not the only thing I'm chasing; I've struck out with a few other publications lately as well.
I'm not discouraged, exactly—mostly I'm just venting fresh frustration. I know I'll continue to write and submit, but man, rejection stings.
Writers of Bear Blog, please tell me...
Have you ever been published? If so, where? How?
If not, what's your dream publication?
If you've been rejected, how do you shake it off and keep going?
I am genuinely, deeply curious.
(Photo courtesy of HBO's Girls...IYKYK.)
Update: Hi there! Me again. A couple quick things...
I was leaving for jury duty when I hit publish on this post yesterday. We weren't allowed to use phones or laptops in the courtroom, so when I got out and saw it sitting at #7 on the Trending page, I re-skimmed it and found several parts to be a bit clunky. Once I got home, I tightened and clarified a few things, particularly in the "I've had four 'Tiny Love Stories'..." paragraph. While nothing was changed factually, the updated version was different enough from the original that it felt dishonest not to disclose that edits were made.
P.S. I'm still curious to know about your publishing journey...if you care to share.
Speaking of...an honest comment from Rei:
I'm not trying to get published in any magazines or newsletters yet, but journalism's a career I'm wanting to potentially go into, so the challenge of my writing getting rejected is a pretty monolithic one to me, HAHA!